What is the difference between….all the functions that find a substring 1st position?

Before tackling the differences, let’s recap the similiarities:

1. They’re all used to locate one string within another by identifying its first positon. 

2. Unlike their Excel counterparts, they will all return 0 if the substring under scrutiny cannot be found

To better illustrate the differences between the functions, I’ll be using the ‘TED Talks’ dataset from Kaggle, to look at the tags given to each Ted talk.

I want to identify the first position of both ‘technology’ and ‘TED‘, so that I could extract them in a separate string

(1) SQL Server: charindex() and patindex()

Consult the snippet below:

	——————–SQL Server——————————————-
	select
	tags,
	charindex('technology', tags) as char_position_tech,
	patindex('technology', tags) as pat_position_tech,
	patindex('%technology%', tags) as pat_position_tech_2,
	charindex('Technology', tags) as char_position_Tech,
	patindex('%Technology%', tags) as pat_position_Tech,
	charindex('TED%', tags) as char_position_TED,
	patindex('%TED%', tags) as pat_position_TED
	from datageeking.dbo.ted_talks
	/*tags |char_position_tech |pat_position_tech |pat_position_tech_2 |
	————————————————————————————-|——————-|——————|——————–|
	['alternative energy', 'energy', 'exploration', 'green', 'science', 'technology'] |70 |0 |70 |
	['DNA', 'biology', 'business', 'genetics', 'life', 'science', 'technology'] |64 |0 |64 |
	['TED Brain Trust', 'children', 'creativity', 'education', 'invention'] |0 |0 |0 |
	['TEDx', 'business', 'creativity', 'culture', 'design', 'fashion', 'law', 'media'] |0 |0 |0 |
	['TED Fellows', 'children', 'culture', 'film', 'politics', 'suicide', 'war'] |0 |0 |0 |
	['AIDS', 'HIV', 'Vaccines', 'disease', 'global issues', 'health', 'medicine'] |0 |0 |0 |
	['cities', 'music', 'performance', 'poetry', 'storytelling'] |0 |0 |0 |
	['Internet', 'TEDx', 'law', 'music', 'online video', 'technology', 'web'] |55 |0 |55 |
	tags |char_position_Tech |pat_position_Tech |
	————————————————————————————-|——————-|——————|
	['alternative energy', 'energy', 'exploration', 'green', 'science', 'technology'] |70 |70 |
	['DNA', 'biology', 'business', 'genetics', 'life', 'science', 'technology'] |64 |64 |
	['TED Brain Trust', 'children', 'creativity', 'education', 'invention'] |0 |0 |
	['TEDx', 'business', 'creativity', 'culture', 'design', 'fashion', 'law', 'media'] |0 |0 |
	['TED Fellows', 'children', 'culture', 'film', 'politics', 'suicide', 'war'] |0 |0 |
	['AIDS', 'HIV', 'Vaccines', 'disease', 'global issues', 'health', 'medicine'] |0 |0 |
	['cities', 'music', 'performance', 'poetry', 'storytelling'] |0 |0 |
	['Internet', 'TEDx', 'law', 'music', 'online video', 'technology', 'web'] |55 |55 |x
	tags |char_position_TED |pat_position_TED
	————————————————————————————-|——————|———-
	['alternative energy', 'energy', 'exploration', 'green', 'science', 'technology'] |0 |0
	['DNA', 'biology', 'business', 'genetics', 'life', 'science', 'technology'] |0 |0
	['TED Brain Trust', 'children', 'creativity', 'education', 'invention'] |0 |3
	['TEDx', 'business', 'creativity', 'culture', 'design', 'fashion', 'law', 'media'] |0 |3
	['TED Fellows', 'children', 'culture', 'film', 'politics', 'suicide', 'war'] |0 |3
	['AIDS', 'HIV', 'Vaccines', 'disease', 'global issues', 'health', 'medicine'] |0 |0
	['cities', 'music', 'performance', 'poetry', 'storytelling'] |0 |0
	['Internet', 'TEDx', 'law', 'music', 'online video', 'technology', 'web'] |0 |15
	*/

view raw
SQL_charindex_vs_patindex.sql
hosted with ❤ by GitHub

Whilst both are case insensitive and could easily be used interchangeably if you’re searching for a precise string, that’s not the case if you’re after a string that could have differences in spelling or vary slightly throughout the dataset

NB! Note that patindex() always requires you to encircle your string in % signs. Else, it won’t find it.  Conversely, adding % signs to charindex() will return nothing but 0s

Charindex(), however, allows you to specify the starting position of your search. That’s not the case with patindex()

(2) MySQL: instr() and locate()

Alike charindex() in SQL Server, neither instr() or locate() will work as expected if a % sign is included in the search.

Both instr() and locate() are case-insensitive

	/* MySQL */
	select
	tags,
	instr(tags, 'TED'),
	locate('TED', tags),
	locate('TED', tags, 5),
	instr(tags, 'ted'),
	locate('ted', tags),
	locate('ted', tags, 5),
	instr(tags, 'TED%'),
	locate('TED%', tags),
	locate('TED%', tags, 5)
	from datageeking.ted_talks
	/*
	tags |instr(tags, 'TED') |locate('TED', tags) |locate('TED', tags, 5) |
	———————————————-|——————-|——————–|———————–|
	['children', 'creativity', 'culture', 'dance' |0 |0 |0 |
	['alternative energy', 'cars', 'climate chang |0 |0 |0 |
	['computers', 'entertainment', 'interface des |0 |0 |0 |
	['MacArthur grant', 'activism', 'business', ' |0 |0 |0 |
	['Africa', 'Asia', 'Google', 'demo', 'economi |0 |0 |0 |
	['business', 'culture', 'entertainment', 'goa |0 |0 |0 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'atheism', 'comedy', |0 |0 |0 |
	['architecture', 'collaboration', 'culture', |0 |0 |0 |
	['God', 'TED Brain Trust', 'atheism', 'brain' |10 |10 |10 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'culture', 'happiness |0 |0 |0 |
	['activism', 'architecture', 'collaboration', |0 |0 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'art', 'culture', 'entertainmen |3 |3 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'collaboration', 'disease', 'eb |3 |3 |0 |
	['demo', 'design', 'interface design', 'techn |0 |0 |0 |
	['children', 'design', 'education', 'entrepre |0 |0 |0 |
	tags |instr(tags, 'ted') |locate('ted', tags) |locate('ted', tags, 5) |
	———————————————-|——————-|——————–|———————–|
	['children', 'creativity', 'culture', 'dance' |0 |0 |0 |
	['alternative energy', 'cars', 'climate chang |0 |0 |0 |
	['computers', 'entertainment', 'interface des |0 |0 |0 |
	['MacArthur grant', 'activism', 'business', ' |0 |0 |0 |
	['Africa', 'Asia', 'Google', 'demo', 'economi |0 |0 |0 |
	['business', 'culture', 'entertainment', 'goa |0 |0 |0 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'atheism', 'comedy', |0 |0 |0 |
	['architecture', 'collaboration', 'culture', |0 |0 |0 |
	['God', 'TED Brain Trust', 'atheism', 'brain' |10 |10 |10 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'culture', 'happiness |0 |0 |0 |
	['activism', 'architecture', 'collaboration', |0 |0 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'art', 'culture', 'entertainmen |3 |3 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'collaboration', 'disease', 'eb |3 |3 |0 |
	['demo', 'design', 'interface design', 'techn |0 |0 |0 |
	['children', 'design', 'education', 'entrepre |0 |0 |0 |
	tags |instr(tags, 'TED%') |locate('TED%', tags) |locate('TED%', tags, 5) |
	———————————————-|——————–|———————|————————|
	['children', 'creativity', 'culture', 'dance' |0 |0 |0 |
	['alternative energy', 'cars', 'climate chang |0 |0 |0 |
	['computers', 'entertainment', 'interface des |0 |0 |0 |
	['MacArthur grant', 'activism', 'business', ' |0 |0 |0 |
	['Africa', 'Asia', 'Google', 'demo', 'economi |0 |0 |0 |
	['business', 'culture', 'entertainment', 'goa |0 |0 |0 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'atheism', 'comedy', |0 |0 |0 |
	['architecture', 'collaboration', 'culture', |0 |0 |0 |
	['God', 'TED Brain Trust', 'atheism', 'brain' |0 |0 |0 |
	['Christianity', 'God', 'culture', 'happiness |0 |0 |0 |
	['activism', 'architecture', 'collaboration', |0 |0 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'art', 'culture', 'entertainmen |0 |0 |0 |
	['TED Prize', 'collaboration', 'disease', 'eb |0 |0 |0 |
	['demo', 'design', 'interface design', 'techn |0 |0 |0 |
	['children', 'design', 'education', 'entrepre |0 |0 |0 |
	*/

view raw
SQL_instr_vs_locate.sql
hosted with ❤ by GitHub

The only time when locate() can potentially return different results from instr() is when it’s been used in its 3-argument form and a starting position has been specified for the search.

By contrast, instr() always starts searching at the first position – there’s no option to define that yourself.

(3) PostgreSQL: position() and strpos()

Both position() and strpos() are case sensitive and neither endorses wild characters (i.e will work as expected if a % sign is included in the search string) 

Also, neither of them supports an optional argument that will allow you to specify the starting position of your search, so the only difference between the two is the one in syntax

	——————————–PostgreSQL—————————————–
	select
	tags,
	position('technology' in tags) as position_tech,
	strpos(tags, 'technology') as strpos_tech
	position('Technology' in tags) as position_Tech,
	strpos(tags, 'Technology') as strpos_Tech,
	position('TED%' in tags) as position_TED_wild,
	strpos(tags, 'TED%') as strpos_TED_wild
	from public.ted_talks
	/* tags |position_tech |strpos_tech
	——————————————————————————————————————————|————–|—-
	['computers'; 'entertainment'; 'interface design'; 'media'; 'music'; 'performance'; implicity'; oftware'; 'technology'] |108 |108
	['MacArthur grant'; 'activism'; 'business'; 'cities'; 'environment'; 'green'; 'inequality'; 'politics'; 'pollution'] |0 |0
	['Africa'; 'Asia'; 'Google'; 'demo'; 'economics'; 'global development'; 'global issues'; 'health'; 'math'; tatistics'] |0 |0
	['activism'; 'architecture'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'design'; 'disaster relief'; 'global issues'; 'invention'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'art'; 'culture'; 'entertainment'; 'film'; 'global issues'; 'movies'; 'peace'; ocial change'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'collaboration'; 'disease'; 'ebola'; 'global issues'; 'health'; cience'; 'technology'] |89 |89
	['demo'; 'design'; 'interface design'; 'technology'] |41 |41
	['children'; 'design'; 'education'; 'entrepreneur'; 'global issues'; 'philanthropy'; ocial change'; 'technology'] |102 |102
	['entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'violin'; 'wunderkind'; 'youth'] |0 |0
	['creativity'; 'entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'piano'; 'wunderkind'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'invention'; 'media'; 'open-source'; 'technology'; 'wikipedia'] |80 |80
	['TED Fellows'; 'disease'; 'health care'; 'innovation'; 'invention'; 'medicine'; 'product design'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'global issues'; 'library'; 'open-source'; 'technology'] |86 |86
	['collaboration'; 'comedy'; 'community'; 'culture'; 'dance'; 'demo'; 'entertainment'; 'humor'; 'performance'] |0 |0
	tags |position_Tech |strpos_Tech
	——————————————————————————————————————————|————–|—-
	['computers'; 'entertainment'; 'interface design'; 'media'; 'music'; 'performance'; implicity'; oftware'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['MacArthur grant'; 'activism'; 'business'; 'cities'; 'environment'; 'green'; 'inequality'; 'politics'; 'pollution'] |0 |0
	['Africa'; 'Asia'; 'Google'; 'demo'; 'economics'; 'global development'; 'global issues'; 'health'; 'math'; tatistics'] |0 |0
	['activism'; 'architecture'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'design'; 'disaster relief'; 'global issues'; 'invention'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'art'; 'culture'; 'entertainment'; 'film'; 'global issues'; 'movies'; 'peace'; ocial change'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'collaboration'; 'disease'; 'ebola'; 'global issues'; 'health'; cience'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['demo'; 'design'; 'interface design'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['children'; 'design'; 'education'; 'entrepreneur'; 'global issues'; 'philanthropy'; ocial change'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'violin'; 'wunderkind'; 'youth'] |0 |0
	['creativity'; 'entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'piano'; 'wunderkind'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'invention'; 'media'; 'open-source'; 'technology'; 'wikipedia'] |0 |0
	['TED Fellows'; 'disease'; 'health care'; 'innovation'; 'invention'; 'medicine'; 'product design'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'global issues'; 'library'; 'open-source'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['collaboration'; 'comedy'; 'community'; 'culture'; 'dance'; 'demo'; 'entertainment'; 'humor'; 'performance'] |0 |0
	tags |position_TED_wild |strpos_TED_wild
	——————————————————————————————————————————|——————|—-
	['computers'; 'entertainment'; 'interface design'; 'media'; 'music'; 'performance'; implicity'; oftware'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['MacArthur grant'; 'activism'; 'business'; 'cities'; 'environment'; 'green'; 'inequality'; 'politics'; 'pollution'] |0 |0
	['Africa'; 'Asia'; 'Google'; 'demo'; 'economics'; 'global development'; 'global issues'; 'health'; 'math'; tatistics'] |0 |0
	['activism'; 'architecture'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'design'; 'disaster relief'; 'global issues'; 'invention'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'art'; 'culture'; 'entertainment'; 'film'; 'global issues'; 'movies'; 'peace'; ocial change'] |0 |0
	['TED Prize'; 'collaboration'; 'disease'; 'ebola'; 'global issues'; 'health'; cience'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['demo'; 'design'; 'interface design'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['children'; 'design'; 'education'; 'entrepreneur'; 'global issues'; 'philanthropy'; ocial change'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'violin'; 'wunderkind'; 'youth'] |0 |0
	['creativity'; 'entertainment'; 'music'; 'performance'; 'piano'; 'wunderkind'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'invention'; 'media'; 'open-source'; 'technology'; 'wikipedia'] |0 |0
	['TED Fellows'; 'disease'; 'health care'; 'innovation'; 'invention'; 'medicine'; 'product design'] |0 |0
	['business'; 'collaboration'; 'culture'; 'global issues'; 'library'; 'open-source'; 'technology'] |0 |0
	['collaboration'; 'comedy'; 'community'; 'culture'; 'dance'; 'demo'; 'entertainment'; 'humor'; 'performance'] |0 |0
	*
	***/

view raw
SQL_position_vs_strpos.sql
hosted with ❤ by GitHub

To sum up:

Syntax	Does it support optional arguments?	Does it support wild characters?	Is it case sensitive?
CHARINDEX ( expressionToFind , expressionToSearch [ , start_location ]	yes	no	no
PATINDEX ( ‘%pattern%’ , expression )	no	yes	no
INSTR (str,substr)	no	no	no
LOCATE (substr,str,[pos])	yes	no	no
POSITION (substring in string)	no	no	yes
STRPOS (string, substring)	no	no	yes

Happy SQL-ing!